Ever wondered how two people can see the same situation so differently? This conundrum lies in the concept of perspective: each individual’s unique way of perceiving and interpreting an event, object, or situation. Indeed, perspective shapes how we understand the world around us and influences the way we communicate with others.
Are we all seeing the world through our own unique set of goggles? It certainly seems that way. Our individual perspectives are shaped by various factors such as our upbringing, culture, experiences, and even our current mood.
By recognizing and considering these factors, we can begin to appreciate the range of perspectives that exist and attempt to bridge the gap between our own understanding and that of others.
Throughout this article, we will delve more into the definition of perspective and provide examples that demonstrate the infinite variations that stem from our distinct lenses on the world.
Definition of Perspective
The word “perspective” has several meanings in different contexts. It can refer to a way of looking at things, opinions, or viewpoints. Here are some synonyms and related words:
- Vantage point
Linear perspective is a technique used in art to create an illusion of depth in a two-dimensional space. This technique, invented during the Renaissance period, is based on the observation that objects appear smaller as they get farther away from the viewer.
By using converging lines that meet at a vanishing point, artists can create a realistic representation of a three-dimensional scene on a flat surface.
Aerial perspective, also known as atmospheric perspective, is another technique used to create a sense of depth in a two-dimensional space. Unlike linear perspective, aerial perspective relies on the natural fading of colors and details as they recede into the distance. When objects are farther away, they become less distinct and take on a bluish hue due to the scattering of light in the atmosphere.
One-point perspective is a type of linear perspective where all lines converge to a single vanishing point. This method is commonly used in art when a scene has a strong central focus, such as a road extending into the distance or a hallway stretching away from the viewer.
When using one-point perspective, artists can create a sense of depth by adjusting the angles of lines and the sizes of objects in relation to the vanishing point.
Two-point perspective is a variation of linear perspective where lines converge to two separate vanishing points. This technique is often used when an object is viewed from an angle or when a scene contains multiple planes.
In two-point perspective, each set of parallel lines on an object will converge to a different vanishing point, allowing the artist to create a more complex composition.
Three-point perspective is another variation of linear perspective that uses three vanishing points. This technique creates an even more immersive sense of depth and is most commonly used to depict skyscrapers or other tall objects viewed from a low or high angle.
When using three-point perspective, artists need to consider not only the horizontal planes, but also the vertical planes, as all lines eventually converge to one of the three vanishing points.
The concept of historical perspective can be traced back to ancient civilizations, such as the Babylonian, Egyptian, Greek, and Chinese cultures. In each of these societies, individuals sought to understand their place in history and how the past impacted their present and future.
Key thinkers, such as the Greek historian Herodotus, pioneered the study of history by documenting events and examining causes and effects. These early historians recognized that human actions and decisions shaped the course of history, and they sought to provide insight to empower future generations.
During the Renaissance period, historical perspective evolved even further as scholars rediscovered and analyzed ancient texts. The work of early historians played a vital role in the development of a cultural and societal understanding of the past, and this in turn influenced the way they viewed the world.
Did You Know? The Renaissance period revolutionized artistic perspective.
As historical perspectives deepened and broadened, the importance of understanding different contexts and narratives grew.
Some examples of historical perspectives include:
- Chronological Perspective
This approach examines history based on a linear progression of time, focusing on events and developments in a specific order. This perspective helps to understand the sequence of events and their impact throughout history.
- Thematic Perspective
Thematic historical perspectives focus on specific themes, ideas, or trends occurring throughout history. By examining specific subjects, historians can better understand the significance and reoccurrence of certain ideas or developments.
- Comparative Perspective
In comparative historical perspectives, historians analyze and compare different societies, cultures, or time periods to identify similarities and differences. This approach helps to reveal broader patterns in history and shed light on shared experiences or unique characteristics across diverse settings.
Pro Tip: Keeping an open mind allows us to understand perspectives better.
Importance of Perspective
Real-life Instances Where Perspective Plays a Vital Role
- In politics, varying perspectives can lead to different policy decisions, impacting society.
- In interpersonal relationships, perspective-taking fosters empathy and understanding.
- In art, an artist’s perspective influences the interpretation and meaning of their work.
Role of Perspective in Daily Life
Perspective shapes one’s thoughts, emotions, and behavior. It provides a lens through which individuals interpret information and experiences, guiding decisions and actions.
Visual Realism, Depth, and Dimension
In art and design, perspective determines the depth, dimension, and realism of an image. Mastering techniques like linear or atmospheric perspective enables artists to create convincing visual representations of the world.
Emotion and Storytelling
Perspective influences emotion and storytelling in creative works, such as literature, film, and theater. Characters and narrators with distinct perspectives convey unique insights and emotions that engage audiences.
Impact on Understanding
Considering different perspectives enhances comprehension and critical thinking during discussions or debates. It allows individuals to evaluate various viewpoints, leading to a richer understanding of complex issues.
Development of Ideas
Perspective contributes to the development and refinement of ideas. By gathering diverse perspectives, one can rethink, reevaluate, and improve upon existing beliefs to foster innovation and progress.
Perspective in Literature
How Perspective Influences Storytelling
Perspective plays a crucial role in storytelling, as it helps shape the reader’s understanding of the plot, characters, and setting. Different perspectives can lead to unique interpretations of the same events, lending depth and variety to a story.
An author might choose to use a first-person perspective to provide an intimate view of a character’s emotions, whereas a third-person narrative may offer a more comprehensive view of the story.
Characters and Narration
In literature, the narrative perspective often dictates how the characters and their actions are presented.
- A first-person narratorial voice may offer readers an insight into the protagonist’s inner thoughts, emotions, and motivations, allowing them to empathize with the character. However, this perspective might limit the reader’s understanding of the other characters and events, as they are presented only through the eyes of the narrator.
- On the other hand, a third-person perspective allows the author to present multiple characters’ points of view, enhancing the overall plot and providing a broader understanding of the narrative.
Additionally, the use of an omniscient narrator can provide readers with a greater sense of the story’s progression and socio-historical context.
Voice and Tone
The choice of perspective also impacts the voice and tone of a literary piece.
Example: A first-person narration typically has a more personal and informal tone, whereas a third-person narration may be more objective and formal.
The choice of voice can also affect the mood and atmosphere of the story, either by building suspense or emphasizing the emotions and inner workings of the characters.
Did You Know? The 'stream of consciousness' technique gives us direct insight into a character's perspective.
Perspective in Art
Perspective in Drawing: Manipulating Space
Perspective in art refers to the technique used to represent three-dimensional objects and depth on a two-dimensional surface, such as a canvas or paper. Artists use perspective drawing to create a sense of space by manipulating lines and angles to imply distance and scale.
Creating a Sense of Depth through Perspective
Achieving a sense of depth is crucial in creating realistic and engaging artworks. Perspective plays a vital role in depicting this depth by using size, overlapping, shading, and placement to convey the illusion of distance between objects.
As objects get further away, they appear smaller and less detailed. Overlapping objects also help to create depth as they suggest some objects are in front of others.
The Role of the Viewer’s Position in Artistic Perspective
The viewer’s position has a significant impact on the perspective of an artwork. Artists consider the viewer’s eye level, or the horizon line, when determining how to position elements within the scene.
By manipulating the vantage point, artists can create different perspectives and evoke specific emotions or reactions from their audience.
Impact of Perspective in Art
Perspective has been a crucial element in art throughout history, greatly influencing the way artists create visually engaging and realistic works.
The mastery of perspective techniques has allowed artists to convincingly represent complex structures, scenes, and objects on a two-dimensional surface, providing viewers with a more immersive and believable experience.
Beliefs and Experiences
Psychological perspective refers to the way an individual’s beliefs and experiences shape their understanding of the world. It is an essential concept in the field of psychology, as it helps explain variations in human thought and behavior.
Example: One’s upbringing, culture, and social interactions can significantly influence their worldview, impacting their cognitive processes and decision-making abilities.
An individual’s beliefs and experiences have a significant effect on their cognitive style — the way they solve problems, learn from experiences, and process information. These cognitive styles can differ from person to person and are categorized into two primary types:
- Analytic styles: Analytic thinkers tend to concentrate on details and logic.
- Holistic styles: Holistic thinkers focus on general patterns and relationships.
Individual and Collective Perspectives
While psychological perspectives are primarily concerned with individual thought processes, it is also essential to recognize the role of collective perspectives in shaping an individual’s understanding.
A collective perspective is a shared belief or set of beliefs held by a group of people, such as within a community, organization, or culture. These shared perspectives can significantly influence an individual’s beliefs and actions, leading to phenomena such as conformity, groupthink, and social norms:
This occurs when individuals adapt their behavior or beliefs to match those of their peer group. Conformity can stem:
- From a desire to fit in.
- To avoid social rejection.
- Because the group’s beliefs are accepted as accurate and reliable.
It is a psychological phenomenon where group members prioritize consensus and agreement over critical evaluation of ideas, leading to flawed decision-making. Groupthink typically arises from:
- A strong desire for group cohesion.
- Pressure to conform.
- A lack of diverse perspectives within the group.
These are unwritten rules and expectations about how individuals should behave within a particular social context or culture.
Social norms guide everyday behaviors and are influenced by shared beliefs and values within the group. Adherence to social norms is crucial for social acceptance and maintaining harmonious relationships with others.
Pro Tip: Awareness of your own perspective can help improve emotional self-regulation.
Perspective in Philosophy
Perspective plays a critical role in the field of philosophy, specifically related to understanding knowledge and truth. In this context, perspective refers to the individual viewpoints and mental frameworks that are brought to bear on philosophical issues.
One key aspect of perspective in philosophy is the concept of relativism. Relativism posits that reality and truth are subjective and dependent on the observer.
This viewpoint challenges the idea of objective truth, suggesting that multiple, co-existing perspectives can all contribute valuable insights and understanding.
Different philosophical theories emphasize the importance of perspective as well:
- Empiricism asserts that all knowledge is derived from sensory experience. In this framework, individual perspective plays a role in shaping the interpretation of sensory data.
- Rationalism emphasizes the role of reason in acquiring knowledge. Here, perspective is linked to one’s logical and critical thinking abilities.
- Pragmatism highlights the importance of practical consequences as a component of truth and knowledge. In doing so, it acknowledges the role of one’s perspective in determining what is considered valuable and useful.
Philosophers have also explored the limitations of perspective when it comes to understanding reality. Immanuel Kant’s theory of transcendental idealism posits that human perspectives impose a “phenomenal” worldview, which is distinct from the objective, “noumenal” reality that lies beyond human perception.
Despite the various philosophical debates, the ultimate takeaway is that perspective is an essential factor in the quest for knowledge and truth.
Understanding and engaging with diverse perspectives can help deepen one’s comprehension of the world and facilitate the resolution of philosophical dilemmas.
Gender and Perspective
The sociological perspective on gender highlights the ways in which society shapes and constrains the behaviors and attitudes of individuals based on their assigned gender. This perspective often emphasizes systemic inequalities that stem from traditional gender roles.
- Women may face challenges related to the wage gap, limited opportunities for leadership positions, and gender-based discrimination.
- Men, too, may experience societal pressures surrounding masculinity and expectations on how they should behave.
It is crucial to note that societal norms and expectations vary greatly depending on the culture and time period, which leads to different experiences of gender across the globe.
The international perspective in sociology aims to analyze how societies and cultures across the world are interconnected and interdependent.
Some key areas of focus within the international perspective include:
- Global economic disparities
- The impact of globalization on local communities
- Cross-cultural communication
- Issues related to migration and diaspora
In conclusion, the sociological perspective serves as a tool for understanding the complex dynamics of societies on both a micro and macro level.
By examining gender and international perspectives, we can better comprehend how collective perspectives shape and influence the social, political, and economic landscapes that individuals navigate daily.
Perspective by Gender
Role of Female Perspective
The female perspective plays a crucial role in understanding societal norms and expectations. Women have experienced unique challenges and opportunities throughout history that provide insight into the complexities of gender dynamics.
Example: They often face expectations related to their appearance, behavior, and roles within the family and workplace.
Additionally, the female perspective offers an alternative view on various topics, which can enrich discussions and promote a more inclusive environment. This diversity of thought and experience is essential for generating innovative ideas and fostering empathy and understanding among individuals.
Impact of Gender on Perspective
Gender can significantly influence an individual’s perspective, shaping how they perceive the world around them, and interacting with others. Some elements that may impact a person’s perspective based on their gender include:
From an early age, children are socialized to adopt certain behaviors, attitudes, and beliefs consistent with their gender. These expectations can shape their perspectives substantially, as they learn to navigate the world within the context of these norms.
Different cultures hold varied expectations and values related to gender, which can influence an individual’s perspective. Understanding the impact of these cultural factors is essential to appreciate the diversity of perspectives that exist within any given society.
Each person’s unique experiences related to their gender can significantly affect their perspective. Such experiences may include discrimination or bias, as well as opportunities and achievements, which can shape an individual’s understanding of the world around them.
By acknowledging the role of gender in shaping perspective, we can better understand the diverse viewpoints present within society and emphasize the importance of inclusivity, empathy, and open-mindedness.
Examples of Perspective
In Art and Painting
In art and painting, perspective is employed to create the illusion of depth and realism. Artists use techniques such as linear perspective, atmospheric perspective, and color perspective to achieve this effect. For example:
- Linear Perspective
This technique involves using converging lines to create the illusion of distance. As objects get further away, they appear smaller and converge towards a vanishing point on the horizon. A classic example of this technique is Leonardo da Vinci’s The Last Supper.
- Atmospheric Perspective
This technique mimics the way light travels through the atmosphere. Objects further away appear less detailed, lighter, and hazier, while those closer are more detailed and have stronger colors. A famous example that showcases atmospheric perspective is the Mona Lisa by Leonardo da Vinci.
- Color Perspective
This technique uses color to create depth and distance. Cooler colors like blues and greens are used for objects in the background, while warmer colors are used for objects in the foreground. This can be observed in Vincent van Gogh’s Starry Night.
In photography, perspective is achieved through techniques such as wide-angle lenses, specialized techniques, and creative positioning. Some examples include:
- Wide-Angle Lenses
These lenses can capture a broader field of view and exaggerate the depth of a scene. This is particularly effective in landscape photography, where it creates a sense of scale and distance between foreground and background elements.
- Forced Perspective
This is a technique that manipulates the viewer’s perception of size and scale by strategically positioning objects in a scene. A well-known example would be a tourist appearing to hold up the Leaning Tower of Pisa in a photograph by standing at the appropriate distance and angle.
- Worm’s-Eye View
This involves capturing a scene from a low angle, looking up at the subject. This perspective makes the subject appear larger and more dominant while creating an interesting and engaging composition.
When it comes to architecture, perspective plays a crucial role in both design and the viewer’s experience of a building. Architects utilize perspective to create a sense of depth, scale, and proportion. Examples of architectural perspective include:
This technique uses a single vanishing point to create depth and dimension in a building’s design.
Example: This can be seen in the long, parallel corridors of a hotel or a hallway in a residential building.
This method employs two vanishing points to represent a building’s design, often used to showcase its exterior. The prominent diagonal lines converge towards these vanishing points, making the architectural design more dynamic and interesting.
Example: A building that can be viewed in two-point perspective is the Flatiron Building in New York City.
This type of perspective involves three vanishing points, with one above or below the horizon line. It is frequently used in complex and dramatic compositions, particularly when depicting high or low angle views.
This view is taken from above, looking down at the structure, offering a bird’s-eye view of the layout and form of a building. Aerial photography and satellite imaging often capture buildings from an aerial perspective, giving viewers a unique understanding of a building’s scale and context within its environment.
Challenges in Achieving Perspective
In creating art or visual content, distortions can be a challenge when attempting to achieve proper perspective. Distortions may arise due to the position of the viewer, the angle of the camera, or the natural curvature of lines in the environment.
Example: When capturing images of tall buildings, the lines may appear converging, creating a sense of distortion.
To deal with distortions, artists and photographers can:
- Use specialized lenses to correct the distortions.
- Adjust the position of the viewer or the camera to minimize errors.
- Implement digital or manual correction techniques.
Limitations of Medium
Another challenge when working with perspective is the limitations of the medium used. Traditional mediums, like painting or drawing, can have certain constraints that make it difficult to achieve a realistic sense of perspective. These limitations may include:
- Space constraints: Limited canvas or paper size may not allow proper scaling and positioning to achieve perspective
- Uneven surfaces: Painting or drawing on uneven or curved surfaces can deter accurate perspective
- Inability to manipulate materials: Some mediums are not easily adjusted once placed on a surface, which can create issues when refining perspective
Despite these challenges, artists and photographers can use various techniques and tools to help achieve accurate perspective in their work.
The Role of Perspective in Communication
Perspective plays a crucial role in communication as it can influence how individuals interpret messages and interact with one another. People often approach conversations with their own unique viewpoints, experiences, and cultural backgrounds.
These factors can lead to different interpretations of the shared information, and can affect the success of the communication between the parties involved.
Example: A sender and receiver may interpret a message differently based on their personal experiences. The sender might use specific word choices or phrases that hold a particular meaning to them. However, the receiver, having their own unique perspective, may understand the message in a different way than the sender intended.
This miscommunication can result in confusion, misunderstanding, or even conflict.
In addition, perspective can also impact the way people perceive non-verbal cues, such as body language and tone of voice, in communication. Factors such as cultural differences and personal biases can lead to varying interpretations of these cues. For instance:
- In some cultures, strong eye contact is seen as a sign of confidence and sincerity.
- In other cultures, direct eye contact can be perceived as rude or aggressive.
Understanding the role of perspective in communication can help individuals become more effective communicators by:
- Being aware of their own biases and assumptions when interpreting messages.
- Considering different viewpoints and experiences that others may bring to the conversation.
- Clarifying their intentions and meanings to avoid misunderstandings.
- Adapting their communication style to suit the perspective of their communication partner.
Recognizing and addressing differing perspectives in communication can lead to improved relationships, reduced misunderstandings, and more effective collaboration among individuals.
It is essential for communicators to be aware of the impact that perspective can have on the success of their discussions, and to be open to considering alternative viewpoints to foster productive and meaningful conversations.
Pro Tip: Effective communication involves acknowledging and understanding the perspectives of others.
Walking in Another’s Shoes: The Skill of Perspective Taking
Perspective taking is the ability to see a situation from another person’s point of view. It requires individuals to step outside their own thoughts, feelings, and experiences to understand how others may interpret or react to a given situation. This cognitive skill is crucial for:
- Building empathy.
- Enhancing effective communication.
- Fostering positive relationships.
Empathy: The Perspective-Taking Gift
One of the primary benefits of perspective taking is the development of empathy, which is the ability to share and understand the emotions of others. By recognizing and validating someone’s feelings, individuals can foster emotional connections and minimize misunderstandings.
Empathy can be especially valuable in personal relationships, as it promotes mutual respect, trust, and compassion.
Negotiations: Winning with Perspective
In addition to fostering empathy, perspective taking is also essential in negotiations.
Understanding the wants, needs, and concerns of the opposing party allows individuals to find common ground and develop mutually beneficial agreements. This avoids adversarial situations and can lead to more successful collaborations in various contexts, whether in business, politics, or interpersonal situations.
Conflict Resolution: Perspective as Peacemaker
Another area in which perspective taking plays a crucial role is conflict resolution. By stepping into another’s shoes, individuals can better comprehend the motivations and intentions behind certain actions. This understanding can help:
- De-escalate tensions.
- Facilitate compromise.
- Encourage a more open, honest dialogue.
In turn, it can lead to the resolution of conflicts and the prevention of future issues.
Personal Benefits: Perspective-Taking for Well-being
Moreover, perspective taking can positively influence the psychological well-being of the individuals practicing it. They can experience increased tolerance, reduced prejudice, and enhanced feelings of connectedness with others, ultimately leading to a more harmonious and inclusive society.
Did You Know? Perspective-taking is a key component in developing emotional intelligence.
How to Expand Your Perspective
Travel: New Experiences, New Perspectives
One effective way to broaden one’s perspective is by engaging in new experiences. This can include traveling to different countries or simply visiting new places within one’s own region.
Being immersed in new cultures and environments provides individuals with the opportunity to challenge their own beliefs and learn from diverse viewpoints.
Empathy: Understanding Others, Widening Views
Another useful approach is to cultivate empathy and understanding. When individuals can put themselves in other people’s shoes, they are able to imagine different experiences and viewpoints, thus expanding their own perspective.
To foster empathy, it is recommended to actively listen to others’ stories and to practice perspective-taking through activities such as reading literature or watching films.
Diversity: Expanding Perspectives Through Relationships
Building relationships with people from varied backgrounds allows individuals to gain insight into different experiences and worldviews. This might involve engaging in diverse communities, attending relevant events, or taking part in online forums.
Incorporating the following habits can further support one’s journey to expand perspective:
- Reading widely
Books, articles, and news from different sources offer glimpses into various perspectives and prompt individuals to think critically about their own views.
- Engaging in healthy debate
Participating in discussions and debates with people holding different opinions encourages the exploration of multiple sides of an issue.
- Practicing mindfulness
Mindfulness practices, such as meditation, can help individuals develop a more aware and open-minded outlook on life.
- Being open to change
Accepting that perspectives may evolve over time and being open to new ideas can contribute to an expansive mindset.
By integrating these strategies into daily life, individuals are more likely to broaden their horizons and cultivate a more open and inclusive perspective.
Pro Tip: Engage with diverse viewpoints, cultures, and experiences to enrich your perspective.
Importance of Balanced Perspective
A balanced perspective is essential for objective decision-making, clearer understanding, and effective communication. It helps in avoiding biases and promotes open-mindedness, allowing individuals to consider different viewpoints and evaluate them based on their merits.
Approaches to Achieve Balance
Seek Multiple Viewpoints
One can achieve a balanced perspective by actively seeking multiple viewpoints. This involves exposing oneself to various opinions, experiences, and perspectives. It is essential to listen to different opinions genuinely and try to understand them without preconceived notions.
Apply Critical Thinking
Applying critical thinking skills enables individuals to evaluate diverse viewpoints objectively. This involves analyzing the evidence, considering the context, and questioning the assumptions behind each viewpoint. Being rational and logical in making judgments helps in achieving a more balanced perspective.
Recognizing and acknowledging one’s biases promotes a balanced perspective. To do this, individuals can challenge their assumptions and preconceived notions about various subjects. Reflecting and revisiting one’s beliefs helps in being more open-minded and receptive to new information.
Practicing empathy allows individuals to see things from different perspectives. It helps in understanding and appreciating other people’s experiences, emotions, and viewpoints. By putting oneself in another’s shoes, one can better comprehend the reasoning behind diverse opinions.
By applying these approaches, individuals can develop a balanced perspective, allowing them to make well-informed decisions, foster open-mindedness, and engage in effective communication.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can perspective be changed?
Yes, perspective can change as individuals gain new experiences, learn about different opinions, or broaden their understanding of the world.
Engaging in open-minded discussions, reading diverse materials, and actively trying to see things from different viewpoints can help change and develop one’s perspective.
How can I practice perspective-taking?
Practicing perspective-taking can be done through a variety of actions, such as:
• Actively listening to others.
• Asking open-ended questions during conversations.
• Considering the emotions and thoughts of others.
• Seeking out diverse opinions and experiences.
• Engaging in activities outside of one’s comfort zone.
• Reflecting on personal biases and beliefs.
What is the role of perspective in problem-solving?
Perspective is crucial for effective problem-solving. By considering multiple perspectives, individuals and teams can:
• Identify potential blind spots or biases.
• Evaluate various solutions or approaches.
• Make more informed decisions.
• Foster a more inclusive and collaborative problem-solving process.
What are some cognitive biases that affect perspective?
There are a number of cognitive biases that can shape and sometimes skew our perspectives:
• Confirmation Bias: This is when we give preference to information that backs up our already established beliefs.
• Anchoring Bias: This occurs when we place too much importance on the first piece of information we come across.
• Availability Bias: This happens when we make judgments based on readily accessible information, without taking into account all the pertinent data.
• Groupthink: This is when we adopt the viewpoints of a group without applying critical thinking to different perspectives.
The process of understanding and appreciating various perspectives isn’t merely an intellectual exercise; it’s a vital pathway to personal development and effective communication. This practice assists in identifying common ground, enabling more fruitful collaborations.
It’s important for us to remember that the world is teeming with as many perspectives as there are people. Therefore, actively expanding one’s viewpoint can lead to a deeper understanding and discovery of new insights and ideas. This expansion is instrumental in developing empathy and comprehension, the cornerstone of a harmonious, inclusive, and diverse global community.
In conclusion, make it a habit to continually seek and engage with diverse viewpoints. Doing so not only fuels our empathy and knowledge but also catalyzes our growth.
This exploration, in turn, can unlock a wealth of potential, enabling us to contribute effectively to the rich and varied educational narrative of human society.
We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!
Let us improve this post!
Tell us how we can improve this post?